Skip to main content

Health Checks Explained

The Domain Health Monitor runs 19 individual checks grouped into 5 categories. Here's what each check does, why it matters, and what to do when it fails.

Authentication​

These are the foundation of email deliverability. Google, Yahoo, and Microsoft all require them for bulk senders.

SPF (Sender Policy Framework)​

What it checks: Looks for a valid SPF TXT record on your domain that authorizes your sending servers.

Why it matters: Without SPF, receiving servers can't verify that your emails come from authorized servers. This leads to spam folder placement or outright rejection.

Scoring:

ConditionScore
Valid SPF with -all (hardfail), under 10 DNS lookups100
Valid SPF with ~all (softfail)85
Valid SPF with ?all (neutral)50
SPF with more than 10 DNS lookups40
Missing SPF, multiple records, or +all0

DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail)​

What it checks: Looks for a DKIM public key in DNS for your configured selector (or tries common selectors for your ESP).

Why it matters: DKIM cryptographically signs your emails, proving they haven't been tampered with in transit. Together with SPF, it enables DMARC alignment.

Scoring:

ConditionScore
Valid 2048-bit key found100
Valid key but unknown size80
Valid 1024-bit key (weak)70
No key found or revoked key0
Finding your DKIM selector

If DKIM fails with "No record found", set your DKIM selector in SMTP Connections > Edit > Domain Health Monitoring. Common selectors: s1/s2 (SendGrid), selector1/selector2 (Mailgun/SparkPost), google (Google Workspace).

DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication)​

What it checks: Looks for a DMARC TXT record at _dmarc.yourdomain.com and evaluates the policy level and reporting configuration.

Why it matters: DMARC ties SPF and DKIM together and tells receivers what to do with unauthenticated emails. Without DMARC, anyone can spoof your domain.

Scoring:

PolicyScore
p=reject with reporting100
p=quarantine (pct=100)85
p=quarantine (pct < 100)70
p=none with reporting (monitoring)50
p=none without reporting30
Missing entirely0

DMARC Alignment​

What it checks: Whether both SPF and DKIM are configured (enabling full DMARC alignment).

Scoring: Both pass = 100, only one passes = 70, neither passes = 0.


Reputation​

Domain Blacklists​

What it checks: Queries your domain against 6 major DNS-based blocklists: Spamhaus DBL, URIBL, SURBL, Invaluement, SEM-FRESH, and SEM-FRESH30.

Why it matters: If your domain is blacklisted, emails will be blocked or spam-filtered by the majority of receiving servers worldwide.

Scoring: Clean on all lists = 100, listed on Tier 2/3 only = 50, listed on Tier 1 (Spamhaus) = 0.

Spamhaus Listing

A Spamhaus listing caps your overall grade at D. Visit Spamhaus to request delisting.

IP Blacklists​

What it checks: If you've configured dedicated sending IPs, queries each IP against 6 IP blocklists: Spamhaus ZEN, Barracuda, SpamCop, SORBS, SpamRATS, and CBL.

When it runs: Only when dedicated IPs are configured. Shows "info" status otherwise (doesn't affect score).


DNS & Infrastructure​

MX Records​

What it checks: Verifies your domain has valid MX records that resolve to reachable mail servers.

Why it matters: Without MX records, your domain can't receive email — including bounce notifications, reply emails, and DMARC aggregate reports.

Reverse DNS (PTR)​

What it checks: For each dedicated IP, verifies a PTR record exists, the hostname is non-generic, and forward-confirmed reverse DNS (FCrDNS) passes.

When it runs: Only when dedicated IPs are configured.

Why it matters: Gmail and Outlook require valid rDNS since 2024. Messages from IPs without PTR records are often rejected outright.

STARTTLS​

What it checks: Connects to your primary MX server and verifies it supports STARTTLS for encrypted email transport.

Why it matters: Google requires TLS encryption for bulk senders. Unencrypted email transit is a reputation signal.

MTA-STS​

What it checks: Looks for an MTA-STS DNS record and policy file that enforces TLS connections (preventing downgrade attacks).

Scoring: Enforce mode = 100, testing mode = 70, missing = 0.

TLS-RPT​

What it checks: Looks for a TLS Reporting DNS record so you can receive daily reports about TLS connection failures.

BIMI​

What it checks: Looks for a BIMI DNS record with your brand logo and optional VMC certificate.

Why it matters: BIMI displays your brand logo next to emails in Gmail, Apple Mail, and Yahoo. It requires DMARC at quarantine or reject level.

Scoring: Logo + VMC = 100, logo only = 80, missing = 0 (informational — doesn't penalize your score).


Sending Metrics​

These checks use your actual email sending data from the last 7-30 days. They show "info" status if you haven't sent any campaigns yet.

Bounce Rate​

What it checks: Percentage of emails that bounced (hard + soft) over the last 7 days.

RatingThreshold
Healthy< 2%
Warning2% - 5%
Critical> 5%

How to improve: Remove invalid addresses, use email verification on imports, implement double opt-in for signups.

Complaint Rate​

What it checks: Percentage of delivered emails marked as spam by recipients over the last 7 days.

RatingThreshold
Healthy< 0.1%
Warning0.1% - 0.3%
Critical> 0.3% (grade capped at C)

How to improve: Only send to opted-in contacts, make unsubscribe prominent, match content to expectations, send at a consistent frequency.

Google/Yahoo Limit

Complaint rates above 0.3% cause Gmail and Yahoo to reject your emails. This is the single most impactful metric for deliverability.

Volume Trend​

What it checks: Consistency of your daily sending volume over the last 30 days.

RatingThreshold
Healthy< 20% day-over-day variance
Warning20% - 50% variance
Critical> 50% spike or > 80% drop

How to improve: Maintain a consistent sending schedule. When increasing volume, ramp up gradually (no more than 20% per day).

Engagement Rate​

What it checks: Unique open rate and click rate over the last 7 days.

RatingThreshold (Open Rate)
Healthy> 20%
Warning10% - 20%
Critical< 10%

How to improve: Write compelling subject lines, segment your audience, optimize send times, and remove subscribers who haven't engaged in 6+ months.


Compliance​

Unsubscribe Headers​

What it checks: Verifies that List-Unsubscribe and List-Unsubscribe-Post headers (RFC 8058 one-click unsubscribe) are included in your outgoing emails.

Mailhorn automatically adds these headers to every email — this check passes for all active connections.

Bulk Sender Compliance​

What it checks: A composite evaluation of all Google/Yahoo/Microsoft 2024-2025 bulk sender requirements:

  1. SPF authentication configured
  2. DKIM authentication configured
  3. DMARC policy at quarantine or reject
  4. One-click unsubscribe headers present
  5. Complaint rate below 0.3%

All five must pass for full compliance. The fix instructions list exactly which requirements are failing.

Domain Expiration​

What it checks: Your domain's WHOIS registration expiry date.

RatingDays Until Expiry
Healthy> 90 days
Caution30 - 90 days
Warning7 - 30 days
Critical< 7 days or expired (grade F)
Expired Domain = No Email

If your domain expires, all DNS records (SPF, DKIM, DMARC, MX) are instantly lost. Email delivery stops completely. Enable auto-renewal at your registrar.